WEEKLY STANDARD | 17.06.2015
Confronting FGM in Iran and Iraqi Kurdistan
Female genital mutilation or cutting (FGM/C) exists in the Islamic Republic of Iran even...
stopfgmmideast | 20.05.2015
Campaign in Iraqi Kurdistan: Paying a visit to a Mullah who promoted FGM
The shock was great when the Iraqi Kurdish Xelk Media Network reported about a Kurdish Mullah...
THE TELEGRAPH | 04.03.2015
"If they mutilate my granddaughter? I’ll kill them’. Meet Iraqi village ending FGM
Amirah vividly recalls the day she was taken into a bathroom by the village midwife and forced to...
biomedcentral | 06.02.2015
The diversity of Kurdish women’s perspectives of female genital mutilation
The 6th February is marked by the United Nations sponsored awareness day, International...
WADI | 10.02.2015
International Day of Zero Tolerance for FGM in the Kurdistan Parliament
Wadi, UNICEF and the High Council of Women Affairs launched an event about how...
stopfgmmideast | 05.02.2015
Day of Zero Tolerance to FGM: We need more campaigns in Asia
On the fifth official International Day of Zero Tolerance to female genital mutilation (FGM)...
WADI | 02.02.2015
Four new TV-spots Wadi has produced supported by UNICEF
as part of the ongoing campaign to eliminate FGM in Iraqi-Kurdistan. These spots will be aired by different TV stations...
WEEKLYSTANDARD | 20.01.2015
Female Genital Mutilation a Growing Problem in Iran
The hideous practice of female genital mutilation (FGM) is neither an exclusively Muslim nor a...
ORCHIDPROJECT | 17.12.2014
KMEWO Event on FGC
On November 13th 2014, the Kurdish and Middle Eastern Women Organisation (KMEWO)...
WADI | 09.12.2014
Radio feature on WADI’s efforts to improve the situation of Free FGM Villages in Iraqi-Kurdistan
“Fichar” program at Radio Deng, an independent Radio station in Kalar, did a feature on WADI as...
WADI | 03.12.2014
Kurdish FGM-Free Village invited to Talkshow
Kurdistan's first FGM-free village as talk show guests on 'Binewshe" (KurdSat TV) to...
ekurd.net | 18.10.2014
A Kurdish girl's story of Female genital mutilation FGM in Iraqi Kurdistan
As we all know from news reports from the region, the people of Iraqi Kurdistan have been...
TRUST.ORG | 09.09.2014
Iraqi Kurdistan could end FGM in a generation - expert
Female genital mutilation could be eradicated in Iraqi Kurdistan within a generation, a U.N...
The Guardian | 08.09.2014
Majority in Iraqi Kurdistan oppose female genital mutilation
Survey reveals widespread knowledge of FGM's dangers, with 68% of people saying it...
stop fgm mideast | 29.07.2014
FGM in Iraq: The hoax of a hoax?
Last week a statement by the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) was circulating in Arab...
WADI BLOG | 22.07.2014
Islamic caliphate labels female genital mutilation obligatory
Recently the Islamic state issued a fatwa which called female genital mutilation a religious...
WADI | 14.07.2014
One in four women in Central and Southern Iraq is affected by Female Genital Mutilation, new study suggests
A first independent study on female genital mutilation in central/southern Iraq finds that...
HIVOS | 13.06.2014
Kurdish villages declare themselves FGM-free
For ten years, Hivos partner WADI has been campaigning against female genital...
wadi | 05.06.2014
Cooperation agreement between UNICEF and WADI to combat FGM in Northern Iraq
UNICEF and WADI just signed a contract to boost the ongoing...
Gatestone Inst. | 07.05.2014
Solidarity Against Female Genital Mutilation
"No victim files charges against her own parents." — Rayeyeh Mozafarian, University of Shiraz...
stopfgmmideast | 30.04.2014
Second Middle East Conference on FGM to tackle myths
The Second Middle East & Asia Conference on Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) by WADI and...
opendemocracy | 14.02.2014
Embracing shame: turning honour on its head
The challenge that embracing shame poses to the longstanding perversion of honour, is the...
ekurd.net | 10.02.2014
Continues battle against Female Genital Mutilation FGM in Iraqi Kurdistan
For many years, people have believed that practicing of female genital mutilation (FGM) is...
wadi | 05.02.2014
Day of Zero Tolerance to Female Genital Mutilation; Action in Asia is needed
On the fourth official International Day of Zero Tolerance to Female genital mutilation (FGM), the...
RUDAW.NET | 27.01.2014
A Slow Fight for Kurdistan’s Women
“It is like digging a well with a fingernail. Our work is very slow. But we did make progress.”
DEUTSCHE WELLE | 09.12.2013
Iraqi Kurdistan fights female circumcision
Female circumcision is slowly declining in Iraqi Kurdistan. Years of campaigning and a law...
RUDAW.NET | 29.11.2013
Kurdistan Premier: Stronger Policies Needed to Combat Gender Violence
Two years ago the KRG passed a law banning violence against women including genital...
BBC | 07.11.2013
BBC-Documentary: Dropping the Knife; The Fight against FGM
A BBC-Documentary: Dropping the knife; the fight against FGM...
CPT | 04.11.2013
IRAQI KURDISTAN: WADI shifts attitudes toward Female Genital Mutilation
On 30 October 2013, CPT’s partner organization, WADI Iraq office, organized a press...
AL-MONITOR | 02.11.2013
Female Circumcision Continues in Iraqi Kurdistan
Despite the efforts of Kurdish civil society organizations and the media to shed light on the...
HIVOS | 27.10.2013
WADI’s ground-breaking campaign against FGM: interview
Falah Moradhkin is WADI’s project coordinator in Iraq. He was one of the few who survived a...
BBC RADIO | 25.10.2013
Kurdistan's success in stemming Female Genital Mutilation
Kurdistan is one of Iraq's rare success stories, the region has enjoyed an oil boom and...
GULFNEWS.COM | 24.10.2013
How Kurdistan ended female genital mutilation
Two years ago, FGM was banned as part of a wide-ranging law to improve women’s rights...
the guardian | 24.10.2013
FGM: the film that changed the law in Kurdistan
Two filmmakers spent almost a decade reporting the greatest taboo subject in Kurdish society...
BIOMED CENTRAL | 08.09.2013
Female genital mutilation among Iraqi Kurdish women: a cross-sectional study from Erbil city
Iraqi Kurdistan region is one of the areas where female genital...
wadi | 14.08.2013
Rate of FGM decreases in some regions of Iraqi Kurdistan
The British MP Gary Kent has traveled again to Iraqi-Kurdistan and recently wrote an article...
The Independent | 31.05.2013
Fighting against Female Genital Mutilation in Iraq
It is a misguided belief that Islam requires young women be circumcised...
CIP | 22.03.2013
The Global Campaign Against Female Genital Mutilation Continues
A global campaign to eradicate female genital mutilation [FGM], often misnamed "female...
Kurdistantribune | 04.03.2013
Tackling Female Genital Mutilation in the Kurdistan Region
Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) is defined by the Word Health Organization (WHO) as...
UN Special | 06.02.2013
The long road to the first FGM-free villages in Iraq
According to a large survey conducted in 2009, Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) is...

 

 

 

 


stop fgm mideast | 29.07.2014. original text

FGM in Iraq: The hoax of a hoax?

Last week a statement by the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) was circulating in Arab Social media calling female genital mutilation sunnah (the right path in Islam) and called on all Muslim women to have it done. A number of Western media outlets and international organizations reported this fatwa (religious ruling) thereby warning of its consequences for women and girls in the areas occupied by IS in Iraq and Syria.

A few days later this fatwa was unveiled as a hoax by several journalists with Spiegel online taking the lead. But was it really unveiled as a hoax? Most reasons brought forward are based on flawed information and misconceptions about the nature of fatwas.

It needs to be differentiated between two separate informations. One was the fatwa itself, the second was a statement by Jaqueline Badcock, the humanitrian coordinator of the United Nations in Iraq. Badcock told the UN headquarters in Geneva about the fatwa in a briefing by videolink from her base in Erbil about the fatwa mentioning that according to UNFPA figures four million girls and women would be affected by this fatwa. This was released to the press. Badcock also said that ISIS had ordered the mutilation of all girls and women between 11 and 49. This last information was not part of the fatwa which circulated on the internet and it is not clear to this day where Badcock got this information from or if she was simply misunderstood. The UN is currently not commenting on the issue but trying to verify the information.

The ISIS fatwa which circulated on Social Media says:

For protecting our Islamic nation in Iraq and Syria, our land, and our people, we need to look after our women and their behavior while preventing them from the dreadful modern life they are surrounded with. A rule to all of the Islamic nations, regions, and districts is to protect women as our Khalifa says and prophet says while the mother Aatyia was circumcising a woman, the prophet said, “Don’t get disappointed, that is good for your husband, and your face”.  In another story, the prophet saw the mother Hajer, who had been known to circumcise women, and asked her whether she still practices her job or not, the mother Hajer answered with yes. Then she asked the prophet whether it is Haram or not and he answered her that is was halal and he could teach her how to do it. The prophet said, “it is brighter for the face, and makes the husband happy”. Meanwhile, the prophet says, “if you cut, do not exaggerate”. Abu Harera gives another statement that the prophet says, “All Muslim women, accept circumcision but do not exaggerate on it”.  Therefore, this is a call for all women to get cut.”

After the UN commented on it and several media outlets reported it, the Middle East journalist Jenan Moussa found that her contacts in Mosul had not heard of the fatwa. Several other journalists supported this.

Indeed, many people, including the UN and Stop FGM Middle East, did not take a close look at the fatwa. It was not released recently in Mosul, but in 2013 in Aleppo.

However, does this make the fatwa itself a hoax? Der Spiegel is quoting the Middle East Expert Charles Lister saying that female genital mutilation was not a feature of Salafist Islam. AFP quoted Lister saying: “FGM just doesn’t fit with the Islamic State’s image, notwithstanding how brutal an organisation it has proven itself to be.” The Telegraph quotes the Middle East expert Michael Stephens saying that the fatwa was not written in language that would likely to be used by the group.

This certainty by Middle East experts is surprising. Female Genital Mutilation is endorsed by Salafists, e.g. by the Egyptian cleric Wajdi Ghoneim or the popular Saudi TV Sheikh Muhammad Salih al-Munajjid. While Ghoneim comes from a country where FGM is a widespread practice Sheikh Munajjid is preaching to a population in Saudi Arabia which is in its majority not practicing FGM. Thus, he is not defending an existing tradition but demanding to introduce a practice alien to the people he is preaching to. What makes experts so certain the Islamic State wouldn’t do the same?

In the case of Iraq, such a fatwa would even be mostly inline with local traditions. No statistics exist for the region of Mosul, because of constant security concerns it was not possible to conduct studies. However, several studies exist for the Kurdish region of Iraq, the region of Kirkuk and Southern Iraq – all showing that FGM is a prevalent practice with numbers ranging from 25% to 78%. It would be highly surprising if FGM was not practiced in Mosul as many news articles are now reporting.

Concerning the language of IS and whatever could be meant by “Image” of the group, it must be explained what a fatwa is. A fatwa can be released by the highest religious authority of a country and made public through state media like in the case of the infamous Salman Rushdi Fatwa which most Western readers take as the example of a fatwa. The Islamic State often has fatwas read in mosques. However, this is only one sort of fatwa. The vast majority of fatwas are answers to a question posed by a believer, often about issues concerning daily life like how to wash, food etc. Fatwas can be released by any religiously educated person – and in Sunni Islam there is no prescribed way of getting a religious education, thus the circle of people who can release fatwas is not exactly clear. A fatwa is not binding for the believers.

IS does enforce with extreme brutality what they consider Islamic law such as the proper veiling of women, non smoking and the outlawing of alcohol. These measures are flanked with fatwas, yet, the fatwa and the enforcement are still two different things. Even ISIS would not enforce all fatwas: If a believer would enquire how he must wash before praying, not even the craziest Salafist would think of going to houses enforcing such a fatwa.

The supposedly hoax fatwa by ISIS is a very mainstream fatwa about FGM. Who ever wrote it knows the hadith (sayings of the prophet) which most clerics use when defending “female circumcision”. Contrary to general perception mainstream Islam is not opposed to this practice. There are small groups like the Ahmadiyya which oppose it fiercly, there are individual prominent clerics who oppose it and there are regions where it was not ever practiced like in the Maghreb. However, most law schools say it is Sunnah, sometimes meaning it is a good thing but not obligatory, sometimes meaning it was done in the times of the prophet and not prohibited by him, therefore people are allowed to practice it. Mainstream Islam views it as a private matter leaving it to the parents. However, one law school, the Shafa’i, say it must be done. The fatwa in question reads like a Shafa’i fatwa. It seems quite plausible that IS would make this interpretation their own as they tend to always pick the most extreme interpretation of an issue.

It is also plausible that an individual or a group within IS issued this fatwa as an answer to someone a year ago in Aleppo, but that despite the phrasing “Therefore, this is a call for all women to get cut” it was still considered a private matter. It is also possible that this person did not have proper religious training and his language does therefore not meet high standards of theological texts – apparently those sharing the fatwa in Arab Social media did not notice this though, only Middle East experts were of this opinion. It is also possible that this IS person photoshoped a stamp in there because he didn’t have one handy in war torn Aleppo. It is almost impossible to find out.

Contrary to media reports there is no dementi by IS. Several IS supporters have dismissed the fatwa as a fake in social media, but no high ranking IS official has called it a hoax. On other issues, e.g. when a fatwa circulated which called for expelling the Kurds from Mosul, IS has come out and called this fatwa a fake.

Thus, it needs to be concluded that no one knows at this point for sure whether the FGM fatwa is a hoax or not. Women and human rights organizations in the area of Mosul did not think it was a hoax. One thing can be said for sure though: Where ever groups like IS reign, women and girls are under threat for freedom, well-being and life, whether through FGM or through other measures.